Zillow lead follow-up: 7 templates that book showings

Free to copy — no signup required.

Here’s the number that should change how you handle leads: a lead contacted within 5 minutes is roughly 21x more likely to convert than one contacted at 30 minutes (InsideSales.com / MIT lead-response research). A Zillow lead who emails you almost always emailed other agents too — the first useful reply usually wins the client.

So the real system is two parts: reply fast (here’s why the first 5 minutes decide everything), then stay warm without being annoying. These seven templates cover the whole arc. Swap the {{placeholders}} and make them sound like you.

1. The instant first touch

Send: Within 5 minutes of the lead arriving

Hi {{first name}} — thanks for reaching out about {{property address}}! It's a great one and it is still available. I'd love to get you in to see it before the weekend rush. Would {{day}} afternoon or {{day}} morning work better for a quick tour? — {{your name}}, {{brokerage}}

2. The same-day nudge

Send: 3–4 hours later, if no reply

Hi {{first name}} — following up on {{property address}}. A couple of showings are already on the books this week, so I want to make sure you get a slot if you're interested. If it's easier, just reply with a day/time and I'll set it up.

3. The day-2 value email

Send: Next morning

Hi {{first name}} — while {{property address}} is on your radar, I pulled a few quick numbers for you: comparable homes nearby have been going for {{comp insight}}, and this one has been on the market {{days}} days. Happy to send the full comp report — want me to?

4. The alternatives email

Send: Day 4

Hi {{first name}} — in case {{property address}} isn't quite the one, here are two similar homes in the same area and price range: • {{listing 1}} • {{listing 2}} Want a tour of any of these? I can line up back-to-back showings so you only make one trip.

5. The check-in

Send: Day 7

Hi {{first name}} — just checking in. Are you still house hunting, or has the search moved to the back burner? Either answer is totally fine — I just want to make sure I'm helpful and not noisy.

6. The revival

Send: Day 14

Hi {{first name}} — last note from me. The market in {{area}} has shifted a bit since you first reached out ({{market change}}). If you'd like a fresh list of what's available in your range now, just say the word and I'll send it over.

7. The post-showing follow-up

Send: Within 2 hours of the tour

{{first name}}, great meeting you today! Quick thoughts while it's fresh: what did you like — and what gave you pause? If this one isn't it, I'll use that to line up better matches. And if it is, let's talk next steps before someone else does.

Three rules that make these work

Speed beats polish. A good-enough reply in 2 minutes outperforms a perfect one at 2 hours.
Always end with one easy question. One question gets answers; three get silence.
Stop selling, keep helping. Every touch after the first should hand them something useful — comps, listings, market news.

Or never send them by hand again

Mini Broker sends this exact kind of follow-up automatically — first touch in under a minute, nurture on schedule, AI-drafted replies you approve with one tap, and showings booked straight onto your Google Calendar.

Try Mini Broker free